JUST IN: Benny Blanco Tells Jimmy Fallon on The Tonight Show While Promoting Their New Album ‘I Said I Love You First’, stating ‘I Look Like a Slob Next to Selena Gomez at the Oscars, and She’s Way Above My League, But I’m Lucky to Have Her,’

Benny Blanco’s Hilarious Self-Deprecation Shines on The Tonight Show Alongside Selena Gomez

On Thursday, March 20, 2025, Selena Gomez and Benny Blanco made a memorable joint appearance on The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon to promote their collaborative album, I Said I Love You First, released the following day. The engaged couple, who announced their engagement in December 2024, brought their undeniable chemistry to the stage, blending heartfelt revelations with playful banter. One of the standout moments came when Blanco, with his signature humor, quipped, “I look like a slob next to Selena Gomez, and she’s way above my league, but I’m lucky to have her,” a statement that perfectly encapsulated their dynamic and set the tone for an entertaining night.

A Night of Confessions and Chemistry

The episode kicked off with Gomez and Blanco joining Fallon for a round of “True Confessions,” a game where each participant shares a story, and the others guess if it’s true or a lie. Gomez, dressed in a chic vintage black velvet Thierry Mugler dress, tried to convince Fallon and Blanco that her dog once ran away on a film set, only to be rescued by Paul Rudd. Blanco, sporting a bedazzled lavender shirt and ripped jeans, immediately sniffed out the fib, showcasing his deep knowledge of Gomez’s life. “He knows it’s a lie,” Gomez laughed, conceding defeat as Blanco playfully interrogated her, proving their intimate connection.

Blanco’s turn in the game was equally amusing. He claimed he’d starred in a Burger King commercial as a kid, but Gomez wasn’t buying it. “Why wouldn’t you have told me that?” she asked, her skepticism cutting through his poker face. Fallon, meanwhile, spun a tale about crashing Millie Bobby Brown’s wedding, which Blanco hilariously questioned with, “Who is Millie Bobby Brown?” The game highlighted their playful rapport, with Blanco’s quick wit and Gomez’s charm lighting up the segment.

The Proposal That Almost Wasn’t

The interview portion of the night took a more romantic turn as the couple recounted Blanco’s elaborate proposal story. Blanco admitted it was “the scariest week of my life,” revealing how Gomez nearly derailed his plans. “We had to do a lot of promo for the album,” Gomez explained, recalling how she woke up tired and grumpy, unaware that Blanco had orchestrated a fake photo shoot as a ruse. “I told him, ‘After this shoot, I’m gonna go hang out with my friends,’” she said, laughing at how close she came to skipping the moment entirely.

Blanco, visibly relieved in hindsight, added, “She almost didn’t even come. She was like, ‘I really don’t feel that well. Can’t we just make up the shoot another day?’” His persistence paid off, and the proposal went ahead, catching Gomez completely off guard. “I freaked out! I forgot everything,” she gushed, her joy palpable as she sat beside her fiancé. The story underscored Blanco’s self-aware humor—he knows he’s “punching above his weight” with Gomez, yet his confidence in their love shone through.

A Slob Next to a Star: Blanco’s Fashion vs. Gomez’s Elegance

Blanco’s comment about looking like a “slob” next to Gomez wasn’t just a throwaway line—it nodded to their contrasting styles, evident even on The Tonight Show. Gomez’s elegant Mugler dress, paired with Christian Louboutin pumps, exuded Old Hollywood glamour, while Blanco’s sparkly, casual ensemble and black cowboy boots leaned into his quirky, carefree persona. Posts on X following the episode buzzed about their dynamic, with fans noting how Blanco’s laid-back vibe perfectly complemented Gomez’s polished presence.

Their appearance wasn’t just about fashion, though. Blanco later shared a tidbit about Gomez’s 2025 Oscars gown—a Ralph Lauren creation weighing 35 pounds due to 16,000 glass drops—painting a picture of her dedication to style. “Getting her there was so hard,” he told Fallon, marveling at her ability to stand on a moving bus in eight-inch heels. It was another moment where Blanco positioned himself as the awestruck partner, lucky to be by her side.

I Said I Love You First: A Musical Milestone

The couple’s visit was timed to celebrate the release of I Said I Love You First, their first full-length joint project, which dropped on March 21, 2025. Gomez described the album as “an exploration of each other’s present, past, and future,” noting how its creation was both fun and cathartic. The process deepened their bond, with Blanco’s production expertise and Gomez’s emotive vocals weaving their love story into the tracks. While they didn’t perform on the show, their interview offered a glimpse into the personal stakes behind the music.

When Fallon asked about wedding plans, predicting “amazing” music, Gomez demurred, saying, “We’re definitely not planning exactly at this moment.” She playfully deferred to Blanco for the playlist, a nod to his Grammy-nominated prowess. Their focus, for now, remains on the album and savoring their engagement glow.

A Love Story for the Ages

Blanco’s self-deprecating charm—“I look like a slob next to Selena Gomez, and she’s way above my league, but I’m lucky to have her”—struck a chord with viewers, encapsulating a romance that’s as relatable as it is aspirational. From nearly botching the proposal to goofing off with Fallon, the couple’s Tonight Show appearance was a masterclass in authenticity. As they embark on this new chapter, both musically and personally, Gomez and Blanco prove that love, laughter, and a little humility can make even the unlikeliest pairs a perfect match. Fans tuning in on March 20, 2025, witnessed a night where Blanco’s “slob” met Gomez’s star—and the result was pure magic.